🌸 Now accepting pre-orders!  ·  Reserve your treats →

Fresh-Baked to Order

Warm, Swirled &
Irresistible
Cinnamon Rolls

Pillowy soft, generously glazed, made just for you — baked to order so every roll arrives at peak perfection.

Pre-Order Now View Menu

Mix & Match Your Dozen

Thick, Chewy,
Perfectly
Crafted Cookies

From classic chocolate chip to seasonal specials — choose your favorites and build your perfect dozen.

Pre-Order Now See All Flavors

The Perfect Gift

Adorable Mini
Cakes

Single-serving cakes in beautiful tins — perfect for gifts, celebrations, or a little treat just for you.

Pre-Order Now Explore Flavors
🧁
Made to OrderAlways fresh, never frozen
📅
48hr Lead TimePre-order anytime online
📍
Lexington, KYLocal pickup available
💝
100% Scratch-MadeReal ingredients, real love
Fresh baked goods
100%Scratch
Made
Our Story

Baked with Intention,
Served with Love

Welcome to Buttercup Bakery — where every recipe is made with heart, heritage, and a whole lot of butter. Founded by a passionate home baker, devoted wife, and proud mom of three, this bakery began in a flour-dusted kitchen filled with laughter, love, and the sweet aroma of something always baking in the oven.

Inspired by years of cooking for her amazing family and busy household, she decided it was finally time to share her lifelong love of baking with the world. What started as birthday cakes, after-school cookies, and Sunday morning cinnamon rolls turned into a dream built on one simple belief — the best memories are made around the table. Every order is made from scratch, baked fresh, and crafted to bring warmth and joy to your home just like it does in hers.

Small-batch baking — never mass-produced
Quality ingredients sourced locally when possible
Custom orders and dietary accommodations welcomed
Proudly serving Lexington, KY and surrounding areas
Place an Order
Simple & Easy

How Pre-Ordering Works

📅
48hr Lead TimePre-order anytime online

We bake to order so every item arrives at peak freshness — made specifically for you.

1
📋

Choose Your Treats

Select your items, quantities, and any custom flavors or special requests from the form below.

2
📅

Pick a Date

Choose your preferred pickup date. We'll confirm availability within 24 hours of your request.

3
💳

Confirm & Deposit

Payment link will be sent via text or email. Balance is due 48 hours prior to pickup.

4
🧁

Pick Up Fresh

Collect your freshly baked goodies in Lexington on your scheduled date.

Your Pre-Order Request

Choose your items below, then fill in your details.

Cinnamon Rolls
🌀 Cinnamon Rolls Packs of 4 · from $20
Artisan Cookies
🍪 Artisan Cookies Half dozen · from $18
Mini Cakes
🎂 Mini Cakes Packs of 4 · from $24 · one flavor per pack
Artisan Bread
🍞 Artisan Bread Per Loaf · $20
🧁 Items in Your Order
Estimated Total: $0

No items added yet — select a flavor and quantity above, then click Add to Order.

No payment required now. We'll reach out to confirm your order and total.

Happy Customers

What People Are Saying

We pour love into every order — and it shows.

★★★★★

The cinnamon rolls were absolutely incredible — so soft and the cream cheese glaze was perfection. My whole family devoured them within an hour. Will be ordering every week!

SB
Sarah B.
Lexington, KY · Cinnamon Rolls
★★★★★

I ordered the mini cakes in tins for my daughter's birthday and they were the hit of the party. Adorable packaging, amazing flavor. Everyone asked where they came from!

ML
Michelle L.
Nicholasville, KY · Mini Tin Cakes
★★★★★

Best cookies I've ever had — thick, chewy, and the salted caramel ones are out of this world. Super easy ordering process too. Already planning my next order!

JW
Jake W.
Lexington, KY · Artisan Cookies
From the Kitchen

A Peek Inside Buttercup

🌀
Cinnamon Rolls
🍪
Cookies
🎂
Mini Cakes
🧺
Gift Bundles
🫙
Ingredients
🥄
Made by Hand
🎀
Gift Wrapping
🧁 Pre-Order